Hey ScouterStan, let’s discuss the myths about the Order of the Arrow. Many people believe these myths, but they aren’t true. Let’s address the biggest one.
Myth #1 The Order of the Arrow is a Secret Society.
This is not true. The Order of the Arrow has traditions and ceremonies that are kept undisclosed to maintain an element of surprise for participants. However, Scouting has no secret societies. All aspects can be known by adults and parents, aligning with youth protection and leadership principles. The secrecy enhances the significance of these moments but remains consistent with Scouting’s values.
Myth #2: The Order of the Arrow membership is automatic for the youth.
This is false. Membership requires an election within the unit, involving non-members as voters. Not all eligible candidates are elected. Adults undergo a different process, with a committee vote usually occurring alongside the youth election. The misconception might arise from the encouragement to get Scout-facing leaders into the Order, but membership always needs confirmation either through the committee or a majority vote.
Myth #3 The Order of the Arrow is just for Boys.
The Order of the Arrow has included female adult leaders for a long time. With Scouts BSA girl troops, female youth can now join through elections and the ordeal process. The first female youth induction occurred at my home camp with National representatives present. Since then, females have held major roles, including the last three chapter chiefs in my chapter. The idea that the Order is only for boys is clearly false.
Myth #4 the Order of the Arrow is only for camping enthusiasts.
There is a camping requirement for eligibility to be elected for Ordeal. The purpose of the nights spent camping is to ensure that scouts have acquired the necessary skills to camp independently, which is essential for participation in the Order of the Arrow’s program. These scouts must demonstrate basic camping skills, such as setting up a tent and managing their equipment effectively. This is important because many events in the Order of the Arrow are held at scout camps and involve high-adventure activities. Possessing these skills is crucial for members of the Order of the Arrow.
The Order of the Arrow also focuses on service-based leadership, intensive leadership training, and development. It emphasizes giving back to the community through various forms of involvement and service.
Myth #5 You can’t decline membership.
It is important to clarify that the statement is not accurate. If a Scout qualifies and is elected, they have the option of declining membership. They may simply inform the Scoutmaster that they are unable or unwilling to participate in the ordeal. Some Scouts may feel apprehensive about this process, as they might not fully understand its scope and how it contributes to learning leadership within the Order of the Arrow. It is acknowledged that all leaders encounter ordeals regularly and must face these challenges directly to progress.
Participation in the Order of the Arrow is entirely voluntary. Many Scouts excel in this environment and advance beyond their chapter. The organization offers numerous opportunities for leadership and service to others. Many adult leaders attest to the challenging nature of joining the Order of the Arrow. However, once they engaged with it, they quickly discovered a new dimension of scouting focused on service and leadership, which naturally aligns with community involvement.
The Order of the Arrow has numerous myths. I encourage you to explore its origins and how it embodies cheerful service rooted in Scout values, enhancing leadership development. The Order of the Arrow is a natural progression for many Scouts and Scouters. Do not let myths overshadow the truths within the Order of the Arrow. Keep up that good hard work and I hope to see you on the trail.
